One issue surfaces in virtually every one of Paul’s letters: What good is the law? To most of Paul’s audience, the word “law” stands for the huge collection of rules and rituals detailed in the Old Testament. Whenever he starts talking about “the new covenant” or “freedom in Christ,” his Jewish listeners want to know what he thinks about Moses’ Law. Does God still require obedience?
It is not uncommon for believers to be unsure about their relationship to the law. On the one hand, they have learned that they have died to the law, that they are not under law but under grace and that they should live as free people. On the other hand, they hear Paul extoling the virtues of the law, calling it “holy, just, and good” and describing it as “spiritual,” and they feel a little uneasy about disregarding it all together. The dilemma should be resolved when we remember that God’s law reflects the purity of His character and outlines the standards of behavior that He regards as normative. The flaw of the law is that it cannot bring anyone to regeneration, and to die to the law means to die to all efforts to be justified by keeping it. This does not mean, however, that the law is any less true or that God regards it as less important. It still reflects God’s nature and continues to outline His standards and, therefore, is relevant to the believer.
Paul’s new inner self, the new “I,” no longer approved of the sin that was still living in his flesh, like his old self did but rather, strongly disapproved. Many have misconstrued Paul’s comments as abdicating personal responsibility for his sin by embracing a form of Greek dualism. Dualism taught that the body is evil and the spirit is good, so its adherents sinned with impunity by claiming they were not responsible; their sin was entirely the product of their physical bodies, while their spirits remained untouched and unsullied. But the apostle has already acknowledged personal guilt for his sin. His sin does not flow out of his new redeemed innermost self, but from his unredeemed humanness.
The flesh serves as a base camp from which sin operates in the Christian’s life. It is not sinful inherently, but because of its fallenness, it is still subject to sin and is thoroughly contaminated. The law of sin operates in the members of our bodies—that is, our unredeemed and still sinful humanness—waging war against our desire to obey God’s law.
The believer who holds the law of God in high regard will, like Paul, find himself in something of a battle. One part of him will give assent to the goodness of the law, but another part of him will rebel against it. In response to the principles of God outlined in the law, one part of the believer will aspire to great deeds, but another part will pull him back from achieving them. Challenged by the law to be done with lesser things, the believer may resolve to change his ways only to find that, he goes back to do again the things he loathes.
The key to the interpretation and proclamation of this passage is the identification of the “I.” Theories abound, and much exegetical ink has been spilled.
- The “I” equals Paul’s pre-Christian life, in which he was dissatisfied with God and with legalism; what we have in Romans 7 is essentially Paul’s pre-Christ diary. Paul himself, however, does not show that dissatisfaction.
- The “I” equals the Christian. But how does that fit with all of the passages that speak of the believer as free from sin?
- The “I” equals Adam or humanity as determined by Adam.
- The “I” is the sinner (or perhaps Paul himself) viewed from the perspective of one who has been justified. The now justified person re-evaluates his/her pre-Christ life.
- But finally, perhaps the “I” is at least in part the present-day Christian. So why did Paul devote so much space to our passage’s concern if the temptation to sin was firmly in the past? The anguish of our text sounds fresh. In Romans 7:4-6 there is a strong statement of the “already,” but in Romans 7:14-24 Paul details the gravity of the “not yet.”. For now the believer is caught in-between.
Paul’s normative use of body is positive. The body is a gift of God, and it is in the body that the believer is called to glorify God as Paul states in 1 Corinthians 6:20. The word “flesh” on the other hand, is the short-hand term Paul uses when he wants to designate a body or life that is being misused, that is, a body that is controlled by Sin. The positive body in that case has become the negative flesh. It is important to realize that body and flesh do not usually in Paul mean the same thing. And that is why nothing good can dwell in the “I’s” flesh.
Stated in the simplest terms, Paul is describing the sad experience of many a person who believes that the principle “thou shalt not commit adultery” is “holy and just and good” but still has a terrible struggle with adulterous thoughts. Or the person who firmly believes that “thou shalt not covet” is a “spiritual” statement and agrees with it wholeheartedly but has great feelings of resentment toward the person appointed to the position she wanted for her husband (and herself!). They both “delight in the law of God according to the inward man,” but, unfortunately, they are discovering that the law which could not bring anyone justification cannot bring anyone sanctification either. The law pointed out sin in the unbeliever to bring them to repentance, and it goes on pointing out “sin that dwells” in the believer in order that they may look for ongoing deliverance.
The picture of the battle of the soul is clearly sketched by Paul as he carefully chooses words with military connotations. He describes sin as “warring” against the law of his mind with the result that he is brought into “captivity.” It is fitting that he continues the theme by using the expression commonly employed by soldiers wounded in battle and in need of help when he writes, “Who will deliver me?” His response to his own query is as powerful as it is brief. “Thank God,” he says, “through Jesus Christ” deliverance from the ongoing power of sin will be experienced. Paul tempers his exultant cry of promised victory with a balanced reminder: the war is not over and the battle will continue, but with the certainty of victory instead of the inevitability of defeat.
All of us can relate to the fierce internal struggle that Paul describes. Until we stand in Jesus’ presence, we will all experience this battle. The only way to win it is by joyfully tapping into the Spirit’s overcoming power. We simply do not have the power by ourselves to do what pleases God. Even the “good things” we do in our own strength make us prideful and dishonoring to God according to Isaiah 64:6.
It begins to dawn on us that one of the marks of a mature Christian is the awareness of this struggle with evil in our lives. One of the marks of a mature Christian is this honest awareness about who are, honest about this civil war within us. It is to struggle with evil until our dying day. We all struggle. We all say to ourselves, “O wretched person that I am.”
Or perhaps we have outgrown this? Have we become so mature, so holy? Are our lives so together, so we have finally arrived at the point where we say, “We are just fine. We are not like the Apostle Paul?” We say inside, “Wretched are those other people. We have won the battle with our sins; we have conquered our sinful selves and our civil war.”
According to the Apostle Paul, a mark of a mature Christian is that a person continues to struggle with sin until our dying day. This is not a sign of Christian immaturity, not a sign of Christian weakness, not a sign of Christian double mindedness and doubt. This is a mark of a real Christian who lives in a real world and has real feelings inside and real awareness of himself or herself. Yes, we know that we struggle with it.
Sin is responsible for death, not God’s holy law. Sin twists the goodness of the law so that it brings death. This is catastrophic for those who depend on the law for their life and salvation. The law reveals a person’s sinful nature, but it does not change it. Those who are bound by the law end up embracing death, not life.
The law is spiritual because it originates from God and reflects His holy nature. The word “carnal” does not describe someone who is unsaved, but someone who is saved and still battles the flesh-a condition that will persist until the Saviour returns.
The phrase “sin that dwells in me” uses a Greek expression that suggests that sin “sets up house in me.” Paul is not talking about conflict with evil in the world but conflict with evil within himself. Because Paul failed to do only good, he could not completely fulfill the requirements of God’s holy law.
Born with a legacy from Adam that can do nothing right, believers retain the capacity to sin according to Galatians 5:17. They are also gifted with a new capacity from God: the ability to do right. These two capacities are incompatible and irreconcilable. The law of Sinai demands absolute perfection according to James 2:10. The law of sin and death came into being when Adam fell and places the whole human race under this law. It fights against the law of God. The law of Sinai pulls one toward heaven; the law of sin pulls one toward hell.
Just as eternal life is through Jesus Christ, escape from the flesh is through Him, as Paul states in 1 Corinthians 15:57. Jesus dealt effectively with the problems of sin, Satan, and self on the cross.
(An audio version of this message can be found by clicking this link: Romans 7 verses 13-25 Our Spiritual Struggle)
Bibliography
- Jeremiah, David: The Jeremiah Study Bible: New King James Version (Nashville, TN: Worthy Publishing; 2013; p. 1554)
- Briscoe, D.S., & Ogilvie, L.J.: The Preacher’s Commentary Series, Vol. 29: Romans (Nashville, TN: Thomas Nelson Inc.; 1982; pp. 143-148)
- Stanley, C.F.: The Charles F. Stanley Life Principles Bible: New King James Version (Nashville, TN: Nelson Bibles; 2005)
- MacArthur, J.F., Jr: The MacArthur Study Bible: New American Standard Bible (Nashville, TN: Nelson Publishers; 2006)
- Walter F. Taylor, Jr., “Commentary on Romans 7:15-25.” Retrieved from www.workingpreacher.org
- The Rev. Edward Markquart, “I Don’t Do What I Want to Do.” Retrieved from www.sermonsfromseattle.com
- “Limits of the Law: The law serves a good purpose—up to a point.” Retrieved from Christianity.com@crosswalkmail.com